It's almost spring break time, and this year we're going to visit my grandparents in New Mexico. While there we are going to do a day hike and picnic in the
Lincoln National Forest, so I'd like to have something with a little more stopping power should any 4-legged critters decide we would make a good lunch. I really don't think there's anything to worry about (if I did, I wouldn't go), but always be prepared as they say.
Ideally I'd have something like a
Ruger Alaskan, but I don't and can't really justify the cost for one day of activity where I probably won't need it anyway.
I have full sized pistols in 9mm, .40S&W, and a couple of 1911's in .45ACP. I could also pick up a .357 Sig barrel for my .40S&W. The 9mm is definitely out. That leaves .357 Sig, .40S&W, and my 1911's
I thought about the
.357 Sig pretty hard, the whole concept behind the cartridge is near .357 Magnum power out of an autoloader. I wouldn't need anything else except for a barrel, but S&W doesn't offer a factory .357 Sig in the Pro/L lineup so that means a fairly expensive aftermarket barrel is needed. So I ruled that out.
I have some
.45ACP loads using 230 grain Hornady XTP bullets that I've loaded to "+P" velocity. I am getting around 875 fps if I recall correctly. I think these would work better if they weren't JHP bullets though. I haven't done any expansion tests on these myself, but I would expect some expansion and hence less penetration from these. Also there's the whole issue of the possibility of having to use these against 2-legged predators and the legal ramifications thereof that Mr. Ayoob is always talking about. Still, if I had to leave right this second, I would take these as they are probably the best of what I have right now..
That brings me to
.40S&W, I decided to pick up some of
Double Tap's 200 gr hard cast bullets as kind of a back up in case my chosen setup (more on that later) didn't work. They give the following data on the load:
990fps 435 ft/lbs from a 3.5"bbl.
1050fps 490 ft/lbs- Glock 23 (4.0"bbl)
1100fps 538 ft/lbs from a 4.5"bbl.
I'm guessing with my 5" barrel I could pick up another 50 fps, which comes close to some 10mm loadings, although still short of a max 10mm load. That bullet at that velocity should penetrate pretty well, and would probably be fairly acceptable for a woods gun closer to my home where the closest thing to dangerous game is coyotes and feral hogs.
So what did I settle on?
.45 Super. With a few
new springs in one of my 1911's I should be able to shoot this modern update of the .45ACP cartridge. The .460 Rowland would be a better option, but the kit is about $300, and I couldn't really justify that vs. $20 in springs. I picked up
Buffalo Bore's loading that uses a 255 grain hard cast bullet that is advertised at making 1090 fps in a Colt Gold Cup. That's roughly 685 ft/lbs of energy and should penetrate deeply.
It's not .44 Mag territory, but 685 ft/lbs is right up there with 10mm which makes an ok woods gun, plus it was only $20 (and cost of the ammo) which makes it a fairly cheap option.